John Britton is driving me to distraction
I make no apologies for returning to this subject so quickly, because I am fucking angry.
This week, a campaign has started in the UK to ban smoking in private cars, and ultimately in private homes and public parks. I knew this was coming but hoped that common sense would prevail. It hasn’t.
Leading the campaign is Professor John Britton of The Royal College of Physicians. I am giving his full title which he is using in his campaign to indicate what people are up against. People are supposed to be cowed by ‘Professor’ and ‘Royal College of Physicians’ and to tip the cap meekly, and to take every word he says as gospel.
I say he’s a liar.
I have no medical qualifications whatsoever, yet I am calling a professor a liar? How audacious is that? Who am I to go against the might of the Royal College of Physicians?
I will tell you my qualifications.
I am a reasonably intelligent person, with a lifetime of experience. I am well versed in the use of logic and reason. I also know quite a lot about statistics and experimentation. I know how statistics are an indicator only and in no way can be used to prove a hypothesis. I know how to go about proving or disproving a theory and I know that to state something as fact, you have to have unequivocal evidence, born of experimentation to state that it is fact. In other words, I will only except empirical evidence and not some bland “we all know” or “statistics have shown”. A fact is not a fact just because you state it is a fact.
Britton has stated the forty children die of Cot Death each year as a result of their parents smoking.
That is a lie.
There is no way on the face of this earth that he can have any evidence for this statement. There may be statistical evidence, but that is anecdotal evidence, not hard fact. If post mortems found a particular trace element that could only have come from passive smoking, then I would concede that this is fact, but no such trace element exists. They are merely stating that in forty Cot Death cases, that the parents smoked. They are therefore branding these parents with a lifetime of guilt for something they didn’t do, and using the death of babies for their own propaganda. That is fucking disgusting.
He goes on about how smoking causes asthma in children which is another lie.
Asthma amongst children has seen a dramatic increase over recent decades, yet the rate of smoking amongst adults has declined. There is no empirical evidence whatsoever to support his statement that smoking causes asthma.
In his statements, he is very free with such claims that “the smoking ban in the UK is very successful and very popular”. Very popular? There are draconian fines for breaking the law, which apply not just to the smoker but to the owner of the premises. The state have therefore relegated their responsibility to the unfortunate owner to carry out their dirty work for them. The people policing the people. Memories of the Soviet Union? Because of the high compliance, it is assumed that it is popular? Is the North Korean police state popular because no one is complaining?
John Britton is an intelligent man, yet he is using his title and position to promote draconian laws based on false evidence. He must know this. He is helping promote a police state where the rights of the individual are being sledgehammered in the name of children and babies.
Britton is a cunt.
I gave up a 40-fags a day habit for good almost 30 years ago, Grandad, and I’m very glad I did. But I one hundred percent agree with you on this. Like they say: liars figure, and figures lie. And using those lying figures to terrorise or condemn people is nothing short of criminal.
.-= Tessa´s last brainfart .. Plus ca change …* =-.
You are On Fire, Grandad!
You, and your pipe.
Thank You!
Truth is refreshing and necessary.
It is all about the police state.
Side note. – Some claim vaccines cause SIDS/Cot Death.
The government here too is always trying to ban smoking in different places like private vehicles but they’re happy to collect the taxes generated by the sale of smokes. If they keep us distracted by this issue, then we won’t worry about the crap that’s in our food and the crap that’s floating around in the air we breathe.
.-= little red hen´s last brainfart .. The World Traveller Returns =-.
Having read a number of related topics around smoking on this blog and then arguing the points to people e.g. the majority of the reported facts aren’t actually based on any real evidence. Case and point is the Cot Deaths argument above, people just can’t counter argue it, as all their opinions are based on said truths banded about by ASH and the likes.
People now just accept what John Britton and people in positions of influence say is gospel. It’s the brow beating tactic used so successfully by the catholic church over the years now used to the same effect all over again.
The various governments are using people like Britton and ASH to spread these lies. It is pure propeganda – the repetitive assertions of ‘the truth’, ‘facts’ and ‘statistics’. The repetition is working well, as vox-pops prove. The people in the street are now trotting out the same lines, without any question. This is frightening, as it is the way Nazism and other totalitarian regimes get the people on their side.
The people are slowly but surely losing their freedoms under these petty and needless laws. A law to ban me from smoking my own pipe in my own car where I harm no one, is not just a bad law – it is an infringement on my most basic civil liberties.
I wouldn’t worry about this Professorial dickhead. He’s probably looking for a job with the World Health Organisation, yet another unaccountable international quango where anyone with any medical certificate has promoted itself to government minister without portfolio.
He knows full fucking well that there is no such thing as a cot death attributable to smoking.
Nice attempt to use SID (Sudden Infant Death syndrome) to further his own puritannical messiah complex. I’m sure my mother who lost a child (would have been my older sister) would be very interested in his theory considering neither of my parents smoked. Back then it was called ‘cot death’.
If he wants new laws and regulations he can fucking well stand for election. The good news is that the UK government are well aware of the BMC and RCP facility for nutty puritanism.
“The report said passive smoking results in more than 300,000 GP consultations for children, some 9,500 hospital admissions and costs the NHS about £23.3 million each year”.
How are they actually arriving at these figures?
Con – The problem is that with his distorted ‘facts’ and the use of ‘saving our children and babies’ he is whipping up public fervour for the ban. This is exactly the way they operate, so that when they approach the government, they can point to all the ‘support’ they have.
Johnie – Those figures are plucked out of the air. They are based on flawed statistics and wishful thinking. There is no way they can substantiate those figures, because by their nature, they cannot be ascertained. Costing the NHS £23.3 million a year is enough to worry anyone [if it were true], though it’s funny how they never mention the ten billion the UK government get from smokers a year?
And just whose back pocket is this particular Fascist toss-pot in then ????
Haddock – [yes, you too have been demoted] I have no idea, but there has to be a hidden agenda. Either that or he is being manipulated in turn and is too thick to realise it. I would bet though that there is a link with the pharmacuticals who make vast fortunes out of patches, gum and shit like that.
Not one dissenting voice from the captains courageous ?
You might like this book I’ve been reading – Irrationality – quite a bit about abuse of, or bafflement by, statistics amongst medics. I’ve a bit about it at http://blackwatertown.wordpress.com/2010/03/16/if-you-must-wear-a-uniform-make-it-a-nurses-outfit/
Blackwatertown – As bit happens, I have just placed an order with Amazon, so that book has missed this boat. It looks very interesting though and shall go in on the next one.