The Irish Holocaust
Like most Irish, I have been following the fallout from the Murphy Report on the child sex abuse in the ‘Catholic’ Diocese of Dublin.
To say that I am sickened by the whole affair is a gross understatement.
Let’s just look at the facts to date.
- There was systematic and widespread child abuse for at least the last sixty years.
- The abuse took the form of physical and mental abuse, including rape, buggery, indecent photographs and molestation.
- The number of abusers is not known but I think it is fair to say that a large minority of priests were involved.
- Those that were not directly involved with the abuse were complicit by their silence.
- The hierarchy not only were fully aware of all the abuse but actively covered it up with denials, threats and lies.
- The hierarchy’s response in all cases was to move the abuser to fresh pastures, being fully aware that the abuse would continue.
- The hierarchy engaged in a philosophy of “mental reservation” which enables them to blatantly lie while convincing themselves that they are telling the truth.
- The Vatican is fully aware of the extent of the abuse, but is actively involved in the denial.
So where does that leave us now?
First and foremost, because of their admission of the use of “mental reservations” it is impossible to ascertain when the truth is being told.
Despite all the revelations, the hierarchy is still involved in cover-ups, denials and outright lying.
Letters of “apology” from Donal Murray [I refuse to accord him any title such as Bishop or Doctor – he is just a low life bastard] are being read out today in churches in Limerick. Here is a “man” who not only denied that abuse existed but in turn intimidated, threatened and abused those who made complaints, to an extent that one of the complainants – Peter McCloskey – committed suicide after being threatened by Murray on several occasions. This low-life has stated in the last couple of days:
As I look back on that time, I ask myself many questions, especially about the three cases in which the report criticises me.
At no time did I, as an auxiliary bishop of Dublin, receive an allegation of sexual abuse and fail to act.
When an allegation of sexual abuse of children by a priest was brought to my attention, I responded promptly and conscientiously and in each case notified the Archbishop and Diocesan authorities and co-operated fully with them.
I never deliberately or knowingly sought to cover up or withhold information brought to my attention.
This scum is still denying everything despite all the evidence against him. He is refusing to resign, and instead is issuing a mealy-mouthed “apology”. He is so far beyond contempt.
In fact not one member of the hierarchy has offered to resign. The denial, the closing of ranks and the lying continue.
The Catholic Church has lost any semblance of respectability. It has shown itself for what it is – a glory club for those who want power and wealth, and the freedom to abuse children.
It is up to the people of Ireland to vote with their feet. I sincerely hope that there will be a mass exodus from churches today when that letter of “apology” is read out. I sincerely hope that church-goers make their disgust known.
There is no use relying on our government. Cowen is as complicit by his lack of action as the hierarchy themselves.
I am ashamed that I was once a member of that church.
I am ashamed of Ireland.
Are apologies not utterly worthless when offered AFTER being caught?
This ‘mental reservation’ is the greatest heap of bullshit I’ve heard yet. It’s like a bunch of kids playing secret club amongst themselves.
And even now, after all of this has been revealed, they STILL insist on covering up, they STILL insist it ‘wasn’t lying’, and they STILL don’t want any further reports.
The abuse hurt their direct victims, their reaction is an insult to every one else in the country.
Fuck you, we’re ‘the church’.
Excellent post this.
I wrote one too on this disgusting and perduring scandal. It’s hard for me, who does not live in Ireland, to understand why the public puts up with it to be honest. There does not seem to be much concrete action by the people to protest this charade.
Have a good day.
(ps. I have just joined and am looking around WordPress. Your blog would go quite nicely on my shiny-new-but-almost-empty-for-now blogroll.)
Martin – Spot on. Of course the “apologies” are worthless. They were literally caught with their pants down and they still can’t accept the fact. Instead, they are safely locked in their ivory towers and having a right laugh. Until such time as every one of them has been dragged screaming into the courts and branded as pedophiles, then nothing will change.
Fucking depressing.
Goodbadtruth – Welcome to my humble site [and to the larger community!!]. It really is difficult to understand. They will attend church today and pretend nothing has happened. There are many who will deny the whole report, saying that “good catholic priests could never do such a sinful thing”. There are others who will simply refuse to read the report and will convince themselves that it never happened.
I would be honoured to fill out your blog-roll a little! 😉
Hmmm, depressing.
Criticising the powers-that-be and blaming them for our woes is a legitimate (and extremely important in this case) thing to do but, and at the risk of offending some, if the Irish people themselves don’t demand concrete action to protect their own children then one is tempted to conclude that the old adage “We get the leaders we deserve” may well be true…..
Goodbadtruth – It is depressing. Very depressing. Our “leader” [who frankly couldn’t lead his way out of a paper bag] is still cow-towing to the church, and is refusing to call for resignations. Unfortunately, Ireland has a very sad habit of electing the same shower of incompetents into power. There is a storm of protest in the media at the moment, but come the next election……. 😐
EXCOMMUNICATION! I have been keeping this bookmark for awhile,I think i going to do this http://atheism.about.com/od/ideasforatheistactivism/a/Excommunication.htm
Popeye – There is a simpler way. Countmeout.ie. Boy! How Ireland has changed!!
So has Texas.
I was lucky enough to be forced to leave.
Having just lost both my parents at 14, I went into an empty church in the middle of the afternoon to pray, as we clumsily do at that age. The priest came up to me and, having decided that my reason for being there was false and that I was really there looking for an opportunity to steal the silverware, he threw me out.
So I walked slowly back up the aisle, out into the sunlight, and swore I would never set foot in a church again in my life. And I never have.
Ok, he was an asshole, but at least he cured me of Catholicism before I was too deeply addicted.
Goodbadtruth – That is a typical example of the open arms of Christianity as practiced by the church. You were lucky he wasn’t one of the legion of pedophiles? Or probably he was, but just wasn’t feeling randy that day?
Well, if he was feeling randy, he sure had a lousy pick-up line lol!
Pity the government and media were not as concerned
about the 3-4000 MURDERED in the troubles
Mind you the priests are a much easier touch than the
hard men from both sides of the border.
At least we dont have the Irish football teams spoiling
the world cup
Celtic Tiger ?? More like a stray pussy
Barrus – Are you glad you got that off your chest?
The church has always been so, yet the “faithful” continue to fund it’s living hell. Why, why, why? It’s not just the Irish branch, it’s everywhere.
Hi GD,
As a thought shouldn’t it be the priests that stay out of the church?
We’re in a society where our religions (catholicism, consumerism and property) no longer provide guidance or distraction, where our leaders don’t know how to lead, and where many (most?) have lost trust in those institutions regardless of whatever happens next anyway.
“godless and leaderless” = chaos?
I dunno, quite a challenge for this little society of ours!
Brighid – I’m only too aware that it’s worldwide. And so is the Vatican.
Mick – `Sadly indeed, we are a country without any sort of leadership. There are times when I’m not too optimistic about the future. 🙁