Here we go again.

From the first of January If you smoke in a car that has a child in it, you will be fined €100

Of all the petty laws they have brought in, this is one of the worst.  It's bad because as usual the science behind it is rotten to the core.  It's bad because it's unnecessary as most driver don't smoke when there are kids in the car.  It's bad because it is virtually unenforceable. 

This is just another salami slice in the process of stigmatising and vilifying smokers.  It is also dangerous in the precedent it creates.  This is regulating how we can behave within our own property and the next step is to ban all smoking in all vehicles on the grounds that it simplifies detection.  That step will doubtless be introduced on the grounds of "driver distraction" or some deeply flawed "research" that states that a smoker's blood is 99% carbon monoxide and the driver is therefore incapacitated.  After that, who knows?  Banning smoking in private homes?

I still haven't worked out how this law will be enforced.  Check points won't work as all the driver has to do is stub his cigarette before stopping, which means he can only be caught on the basis of suspicion and smell of smoke.  Are squad cars going to follow motorists to see if they can spot the top of a wee head on the back seat while simultaneously smoke drifts through the driver's window?  Are they going to foot-patrol traffic that's stuck in traffic jams or at traffic lights?

On a passing note, a person can hold a full driving licence here at the age of seventeen.  Does the law then apply to that person if they are the sole occupant of the car?  While a seventeen year old cannot legally buy cigarettes there is no law to say they can't smoke them, so they would only be breaking a law that defends them against themselves?

It is an insane law and once again I shall not give it another thought.  The only effect it will have is that I won't bring any child on a long journey so no change there.

There are of course loopholes in the law.

The law applies to people smoking in a car with a child present

It doesn't apply if the child is running behind the car and attached by rope [great exercise involved there?].

It also doesn't apply if the child is strapped to the roofrack.

Problem solved.

Child on car roof

It's only fair to share...Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInPin on PinterestShare on RedditShare on StumbleUponShare on Tumblr


Starting the New Year with Nanny — 11 Comments

    • That is too close to the bone to be funny!  [though I did get a laugh]

      Did they ever introduce it Over There?  There are so many of these damned prohibitions that I have lost track of a lot of them.

      • Grandad,

        I believe it came into 'force' in October but I'm pretty sure it hasn't been 'enforced' at this time. I seem to remember various police forces stating they had other, more pressing, stuff to worry about.

    • Welcome John!  Why do I have the nasty feeling that they hope this law will encourage kids to snitch on their parents?  They really are trying to get society to raise a nasty little bunch of horrors, where the kids nag the parents and ultimately report them to the police.  Shades of Hitler Youth?

  1. This nasty little law has been in Australia for a while now, although I've never seen it enforced. However its a great way to avoid having to pick up and drop off anyone's kids. I don't smoke, but they want to apply this nonsense to vapers as well, excellent, no more "can you pick up what'shisface from school today?" my answer, "no, I wouldn't want to endanger your little darling with my second hand vape, its got nicotine in it you know, your little brat is hyper enough, wouldn't want to make him any worse". I've long banned children from eating in my car, (dirty little buggers leave crap everywhere), at least now I don't have to justify my rules, the LAW protects the little blighters. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hosted by Curratech Blog Hosting