Are you healthy?

They are going to study the state of Ireland’s health.

This should be fun.

My first question is how they are going to do this?  They say they are going to assess 10,000 households, so are they going to call around to each household?  Are they going to examine the medical records of those households?  Or are they just going to phone people up and torture them with a battery of irritating questions?

My money is on the latter.

Now I have a problem with telephone surveys.  In fact my problem with them is so big I would discount them out of hand as being a complete waste of time and effort.

You see our dear Nanny Gubmint has been harping on for years about smoking, and lately about alcohol and obesity.  They have successfully implanted the idea into the minds of the sheeple that smoking is evil; that being overweight is disgusting and shameful and that anything over a glass of beer a week means you are a raving alcoholic.  As a result people won’t even admit to themselves how much they eat, drink or smoke, let alone tell a total stranger.  They will play down the figures and lie through their teeth because they want to give the impression that they are moral upright citizens.

Q.  Do you smoke?

A. No.  *Well, ten a day doesn’t really count as smoking?  And anyway I intend to quit.  Sometime.*

Q. Do you consider yourself a light, moderate or heavy drinker?

A. Light. *Paddy down the pub sinks twelve pints a night so he would be a heavy drinker where I only have eight, so I’m a light drinker*

Q. Would you consider yourself obese? 

A. Definitely not.  *I have been eighteen stone for years now.  It’s my normal weight.  I’m big boned.*

The questions themselves are always slanted and in some cases are impossible to answer.  Take for example the question “Do you smoke?”  I answer yes [though sometimes I’ll answer no because I know what’s coming].  “How many cigarettes a day do you smoke?”  And there is the problem.  I don’t smoke cigarettes [I hate the taste and the smell] and am a pipe smoker, so how can I possibly translate that into their standard yardstick of cigarette numbers?  There is never a question about how much tobacco I smoke, so it ends up with a sort of guesstimate which would be hopelessly wrong.  I have never ever come across a survey that includes a section for pipe smokers.

On the question of obesity, are they going to ask what weight people are?  If so that is a hopeless yardstick and anyway people will always understate their weight [the last time I weighed myself I was wearing pants, socks and a wristwatch so I have to allow about half a stone for them?].  Or are they going to use that old chestnut – Body Mass Index?  Not only has that been discredited but no one knows their BMI anyway.  I cannot think of any form of question that could possibly determine whether a person is overweight or not, as normal weight depends on stature, bone structure and muscle to fat ratios – none of which can be determined by a telephone questionnaire.

As for drinking – no one ever admits how much they drink.  By the time I crawl home from the pub after eight pints I will have firmly convinced myself I had four, and when Herself asks, I round that to three.  The woman who necks a bottle of Blossom Hill a day is going to admit she “occasionally has a glass”.  And everyone knows that a couple of pints at lunchtime with the lads from the office just doesn’t count as drinking.

What worries me about this “survey” is that they are going to take it as a yardstick to beat us over the head with in the years to come.

So if anyone phones you and asks you to take a simple survey on the nation’s health…..

Lie like fuck.

It's only fair to share...Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInPin on PinterestShare on RedditShare on StumbleUponShare on Tumblr

Comments

Are you healthy? — 7 Comments

  1. I have discovered a perfect response to any telephone menace sales individual.   I politely say that I do not answer questions on the telephone.  They usually respond by saying, "Why do you not answer questions?".

    I can then reply, " That is a question".

    That puts them in a quandary and they usually give up.

    • That is an excellent plan.  However I don't mind health surveys as they give me a chance to give some really decent replies.  Surveys about politics though – yes, that plan sounds ideal!

  2. Should a call ensue I think I'll tell them I smoke 300 a day, weigh 30 stone, and that the two bottles of whiskey (one morning / one evening) ensure that i'm totally stress free! If everyone does the same it'll be great seeing Varadkar trying to work out a HSE budget after that!

  3. Hi Headrambles. We, our household, were recently 'randomly' selected by UCD to participate in a survey which, if I remember correctly before shreading it, ran to some 6 pages. I suspected, as we had not participated in the Property Tax until it was stolen by Revenue from my wages, that this was another 'sly' way of obtaining information about us. So anxious were they to receive same information that they sent us a reminder some weeks later of the closing date for returning the survey. As they say "No way Jose". Glad the missus is on the mend again.

    • Like the last census forms that were sent around asking if we had septic tanks and the like?  I can understand the need for some questions but some were blatantly snooping for their own needs.  I give them the information that I want them to know and everything else is my business.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *